Family history investigations · intermediate
25 · One voyage, two reported departure dates
Read a vivid recollection while preserving a small contradiction.
What you can take away
- Compare source layers and retain unresolved date differences.
- Write a 100-word account that retains both dates clearly and describes the help network without quoting invented speech
Your trail through this idea
Checking saved progress…
Duckworth Grimshaw’s account remembers leaving factory work, saying farewell, and finding help during an ocean crossing. Its digital presentation also contains a small date disagreement that a polished narrative could easily hide.
Prerequisite: complete the preceding lesson or bring its worksheet.
Read the evidence
The Saints by Sea excerpt is attributed to Grimshaw’s autobiography and cites a 1969 compilation. Its voyage heading gives 23 April 1862, while the narrative says the John J. Boyd sailed on 22 April. The account describes assistance from another passenger during illness. These are attributed recollections, not reconstructed dialogue.
The GED’s @I107@ identifies Duckworth Grimshaw with life years 1842–1926. The name and migration context make a strong lead, while the exact relationship to the private tree still requires genealogical proof. The date discrepancy belongs to this Boyd source, not to Mette Mortensen’s Thornton account.
Follow the question
Original comparison table: source layer, stated date, kind of event, creation date, and possible next check. A heading and a memoir may refer to different stages of departure, or one may be mistaken. Those are hypotheses; do not choose among them without evidence such as a contemporary shipping notice or port record.
Make something useful
Try this
Original exercise
Write a 100-word account that retains both dates clearly and describes the help network without quoting invented speech. Then list two records that could distinguish departure stages. Explain why changing 22 to 23 silently would make the story cleaner but the research worse.
Keep both statements visible
| Layer | Departure date shown | What needs checking |
|---|---|---|
| Voyage heading | 23 April 1862 | Editorial basis and definition of departure |
| Autobiographical narrative | 22 April 1862 | Original wording and retrospective chronology |
A defensible exhibit caption
The digital presentation gives different departure dates in its heading and remembered narrative. This exhibit retains both while seeking contemporary shipping evidence. Possible differences between boarding, clearance and sailing are hypotheses, not a resolution. The source remains useful even while one detail is unsettled.
Check your reasoning
A quick check · for your own learning
What should happen to the Boyd source's 22/23 April discrepancy?
A self-study prompt. You can retry; this is not an exam.
Keep the result and follow the sources
Evidence ledger: the excerpt and its heading were read; a contemporary departure record was not. Confidence is high in the existence of the discrepancy, not in a chosen resolution. Your deliverable demonstrates that an engaging family story can keep a small uncertainty in plain sight.
Sources and scope
- Edited autobiographical excerpt, reviewed 14 November 2026. Additional direct links appear beside the claims they support.
- Private source: supplied
rassy.gedexport, inspected record(s) @I107@; raw data and living-family relationships are deliberately excluded. A GED assertion is not independent corroboration. - Examples and exercises are original educational synthesis. External sources support the stated technical or historical context, not every hypothetical scenario.