Family history investigations · intermediate
20 · When the tree says more than the evidence
Keep an uncertain relationship open without inventing a resolution.
What you can take away
- Compare alternative hypotheses and define discriminating evidence.
- Write a research question that can be answered by evidence, not resemblance
Your trail through this idea
Checking saved progress…
A tree interface can create pressure to fill a parent slot. Historical evidence may not yet justify a single parent link. The pressure to complete the diagram can be stronger than the evidence.
Prerequisite: complete the preceding lesson or bring its worksheet.
Read the evidence
Consider a fictional historical research case: a compiler has linked a child to a parent, but the researcher has not yet inspected the birth record, household record, or the report behind that link. No actual family relationship is represented in this exercise.
The GEDCOM specification explains how relationships can be represented; it does not adjudicate their truth. A data structure can preserve uncertainty only if the researcher deliberately records it. A visually complete tree is not necessarily a better historical account than one with a clearly marked unresolved link.
Follow the question
Original hypothesis grid: H1 and H2 are unnamed alternatives, and H3 is 'insufficient evidence to choose.' List what each would predict in a birth record, household record, or later account. A source that repeats the same family compilation is not an independent vote. Contradictions should be recorded rather than averaged away.
Make something useful
Try this
Original exercise
Write a research question that can be answered by evidence, not resemblance. Specify which original records and report are needed, what identity checks must pass, and what would falsify each hypothesis. Preserve the current tree assertion privately without publishing it as fact. Do not use living people’s genetic or personal information for this exercise.
Check your reasoning
A quick check · for your own learning
What is a valid outcome of this fictional parentage investigation?
A self-study prompt. You can retry; this is not an exam.
Keep the result and follow the sources
Evidence ledger: this is a fictional evidence-analysis exercise, not a claim about any person or family. The useful deliverable is a fair test plan. Leaving the answer open is a research result, not a failure to finish a story.
Sources and scope
- Research guide or format specification, reviewed 14 November 2026. Additional direct links appear beside the claims they support.
- Examples and exercises are original educational synthesis. External sources support the stated technical or historical context, not every hypothetical scenario.